Bias and objectivity audits#
Audits of analyses 02 and 03 for leaning and objectivity to a journalistic standard: proposals, applied changes and over-correction checks.
Files#
| File | Words | Summary |
|---|---|---|
| Objectivity audit: applied log for 02-huang-analysis.md | 3,984 | Applied 26 September 2026. Sources: 02-proposals-A.md (46 proposals: In brief, §§1–5) and 02-proposals-B.md (54 proposals: §§6–10). Pre-edit copy: 02-before.md. Each proposal was checked against the corrected Whisper… |
| Objectivity audit A: proposals for 02-huang-analysis.md | 9,145 | Scope: In brief; §1; §2 (esp. 2.1, 2.2, 2.4); §3.14; §4 (esp. 4.1, 4.3, 4.4, 4.5); §5 (esp. 5.1, 5.4, 5.6); §3.1–3.13 skimmed for loaded language only. Scope read in full. Evidence checked against the corrected Whisper… |
| Objectivity audit of 02-huang-analysis.md, auditor B: Sections 6 to 10 | 8,208 | Scope: Section 6 (claims and evidence), Section 7 (the strongest case), Section 8 (tensions, assumptions, gaps, position and interests), Section 9 (record and responses) and Section 10 (synthesis). Lines 723 to 1241 of… |
| Bias audit of 03-late-lessons-and-huang.md: applied log | 4,385 | 26 September 2026. This log records what happened to each proposal in 03-proposals-A.md (sections 1–4) and 03-proposals-B.md (sections 5–12 and Appendix A). The pre-edit text is 03-before.md. Each proposal was checked… |
| Bias audit, 03-late-lessons-and-huang.md, sections 1–4: proposals (auditor A) | 7,858 | Scope: sections 1 (About), 2 (In brief), 3 (Framing) and 4 (Dimension by dimension) of 03-late-lessons-and-huang.md as of 26 September 2026, 12:55 (identical to working/bias-audit/03-before.md). Sections 5–12 were… |
| Bias audit, scope B: proposals for 03-late-lessons-and-huang.md, sections 5–12 and Appendix A | 6,616 | Working file, 26 September 2026. It proposes wording-level edits only. No change to the ranking, the structure or the findings. Line numbers refer to 03-late-lessons-and-huang.md as it stands (identical to… |
| Objectivity cross-check of 02 and 03: change log | 3,669 | 26 September 2026. This was the final objectivity read of 02-huang-analysis.md and 03-late-lessons-and-huang.md, made after the audits recorded in 02-applied-log.md and 03-applied-log.md. The test applied was whether a… |